COMPARISON

School AI policy vs. classroom AI guidelines: what is the difference?

A school or board AI policy sets the purpose, principles and expectations for everyone, including privacy and how misuse is handled. Classroom or task guidelines say what AI may be used for on a particular assignment and how to document that use. Both are needed: the policy is the frame, and the task rule is where students learn what is allowed.

Written by David Fineberg · Last updated

How the two documents differ

A policy answers "what do we believe and expect here?" A task guideline answers "what can I do on this assignment?"

AspectSchool or board policyClassroom or task guidelines
PurposeSet principles and expectations for the whole communityTell students what AI use is allowed on one task
ScopeAll students, staff and familiesOne class, unit or assignment
Typical contentPurpose, student and staff expectations, privacy, response to misuse, reviewAllowed uses, off-limits uses, how to record AI use, how work will be assessed
Who writes itLeadership with staff, and often input from students and parents; follows board and provincial or territorial requirementsThe classroom teacher, sometimes with a department
How often it changesReviewed at least yearlySet each time a task is assigned, and adjusted as teachers learn
What it cannot doAnticipate every assignmentReplace shared school-wide principles

What a policy covers

A good policy is short and plain enough that students and parents can read it. It states why the school has it, what students are expected to do, what staff are expected to do, how privacy is protected, how misuse is handled (with a learning-first response), and when it will be reviewed. It should also point people to your board's and province or territory's requirements, which take priority.

Example of policy language: "Students may use AI when the rules for a task say so. Students must be honest about how they used it and are responsible for the work they hand in."

For a full list, see What should a school AI policy include?

What task guidelines cover

Task guidelines are where students actually find out what is permitted. They name what AI may do, what it may not, and what students must hand in to show how they worked.

Example of a task rule: "For this 300-word argument, you may use AI to brainstorm, organize your ideas and check clarity. You may not use it to write sentences. Hand in your paper, your prompts and a signed source check."

That example comes from the free Position Paper Kit and Student Handout, described under free resources.

Why you need both

A policy without task rules leaves students guessing. A student who reads "use AI responsibly" still does not know whether it is acceptable on tonight's essay. Task rules without a policy leave each teacher improvising, so expectations differ from one room to the next, and responses to misuse are inconsistent.

Together they work like a frame and a picture. The policy gives consistency and fairness. The task rule gives clarity. The pairing also supports honest declaration, since students know in advance both what is allowed and that honest use of permitted tools carries no penalty. See Can students use AI for schoolwork?.

Where to start

  • School leaders: draft or update a one-page policy, using the Sample School AI Policy in the free resources as a starting point, and read leading AI in your school.
  • Teachers: add a one-line AI rule to your next assignment: AI-free, AI-assisted with listed steps, or AI-open.
  • Both: agree on a shared wording for how students record AI use, so it looks the same in every class.

Quick answers

Can a teacher set stricter rules than the school policy?

Usually a task can be stricter for good learning reasons, such as making it AI-free. Teachers should check their board's rules and explain the reason to students.

How often should each be reviewed?

Review the policy at least yearly. Task guidelines are set each time an assignment is given.

Free classroom-ready resources

Handouts, a sample school AI policy, a prompt-portfolio set and a printable WISE Compass poster. Enter your email to get them, plus new resources as they are added.

Get the free resources
Free · unsubscribe anytime
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Fineberg is an educator and AI-in-education consultant based in Montreal, working with English and French school communities. He is the author of Teaching in the Age of AI: The WISE Canadian Classroom. He offers staff workshops, consultations and talks through Edify AI.