GUIDE · FOR TEACHERS

Can students use AI for schoolwork?

Yes, when the rules are clear. The question is not whether students will use AI, but which uses a given task allows, and whether students can show they checked and understood the result. Setting those rules task by task, and asking students to document how they used AI, keeps the learning intact.

Written by David Fineberg · Last updated

Set the rules for each task

There is no single answer for every assignment. For each task, decide what AI may be used for and what it may not. For example, a position paper might allow AI for brainstorming, organizing and checking a draft for clarity, and nothing else. A research essay might allow more, with documentation. Either way, say it in writing on the handout.

Make students show their work

The most useful rule is a simple one: students record how they used AI. That can be as light as a source check sheet, where they list the real, non-AI source for each fact. It can be fuller, such as a prompt portfolio, where they record what they delegated, the prompts they wrote, how they verified each claim, and a signed statement.

Teach students to check what AI says

AI tools sound sure of themselves whether they are right or not. Require students to confirm every factual claim against a real source they can name and find again. Recording the result, including claims that did not check out, makes the habit visible.

Ask students to stand behind the work

A brief conversation about the argument, or a short written reflection for students who communicate better in writing, shows whether the thinking is the student's own. A written reflection carries equal weight and is not a fallback.

Assess the thinking, not only the product

When AI is allowed, the final text is not the best evidence of learning. Assess the strength of the student's own argument, whether the evidence is real and verified, whether prompts improved over time, and whether the student can explain how they reached their conclusions.

Two classroom-ready examples

  • Position Paper Kit: a 300-word argument on a real local question. AI may be used to brainstorm, organize and check clarity, not to write. Students hand in the paper, their prompts and a signed source check.
  • Prompt-Portfolio Set: a Grade 10 history research task, with a four-part portfolio, one section for each WISE pillar, and a sample rubric. The structure transfers to any subject where students research and write.

How the WISE pillars apply

  • Wield it: students decide what to do themselves and what to hand to AI.
  • Instruct it: prompts show how precisely students directed the tool.
  • Scrutinize it: every AI-sourced claim is verified against an independent source.
  • Endorse it: students sign their work and explain their thinking.

Free classroom-ready resources

Handouts, a sample school AI policy, a prompt-portfolio set and a printable WISE Compass poster. Enter your email to get them, plus new resources as they are added.

Get the free Position Paper Kit and Prompt-Portfolio Set
Free · unsubscribe anytime
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Fineberg is an educator and AI-in-education consultant based in Montreal, working with English and French school communities. He is the author of Teaching in the Age of AI: The WISE Canadian Classroom. He offers staff workshops, consultations and talks through Edify AI.