QUESTION · FOR TEACHERS

How do you redesign assignments for the age of AI?

Assess the thinking, not only the text. Redesign by asking for process as well as product, using local or personal context AI cannot know, adding a short conversation or reflection, requiring verified sources, staging drafts with in-class checkpoints, and sometimes making AI part of the task so students critique its output.

Written by David Fineberg · Last updated

The core idea

If an assignment can be finished by pasting the prompt into a chatbot, it mostly measures whether a student can obtain text. The goal of redesign is to make the learning visible: the argument, the evidence, the explanation, the decisions along the way. That fits the principle that teachers assess the thinking and not only the product. See Can students use AI for schoolwork?

Practical redesign moves

  • Ask for process as well as product. Collect outlines, drafts and notes on choices.
  • Use local, personal or in-class context. Tie the task to a class discussion, a community question or a student's own experience.
  • Add a short conversation or reflection. A few minutes of explanation, or a written reflection of equal weight, shows understanding.
  • Require verified sources. Students name the real, non-AI source for key claims and say how they checked.
  • Stage the work. Use drafts with in-class checkpoints.
  • Assess reasoning. Give marks for argument quality, use of evidence and clarity of explanation.
  • Sometimes build AI in. Let students generate a response, then critique and correct it.

Before and after examples

Grade 10 history

Before: "Write a 1,000-word essay on the causes of a historical event."

After: Students choose a question, hand in a source list with a note on how each source was verified, submit a draft at an in-class checkpoint, and explain their central argument in a three-minute conference.

Grade 8 science

Before: "Explain why ecosystems need biodiversity."

After: Students observe a local green space, record what they see, and write an explanation that uses their own observations. They may ask AI for a comparison and then mark where it fits or does not fit what they saw.

Grade 11 English

Before: "Write a character analysis of the protagonist."

After: Students bring annotated passages to class, write a first paragraph in class, and then submit the full analysis with a short note on which interpretations they considered and rejected.

A worked example

The free Prompt-Portfolio Set shows one full redesign: a Grade 10 history research task rebuilt as a four-part portfolio, one section per WISE pillar, with a sample rubric. It is available through the free resources. For a related approach to writing tasks, see Do students still need to learn to write?

Where to start

Choose one assignment and make one change: add a process requirement, a checkpoint or a short conversation. State the AI rule for the task in a sentence. Review how it went, then adjust. Ask students what the new requirement showed them about their own work, since their feedback helps refine the design. Small, repeated changes are easier to sustain than a full rewrite of every task. The wider picture is in AI and academic integrity.

Quick answers

Do I have to redesign every assignment?

No. Start with the tasks most easily completed by AI and change one thing at a time.

Is it fine to let students use AI on a task?

Yes, when the rules are clear for that task and students document how they used it.

Free classroom-ready resources

Handouts, a sample school AI policy, a prompt-portfolio set and a printable WISE Compass poster. Enter your email to get them, plus new resources as they are added.

Get the free resources
Free · unsubscribe anytime
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Fineberg is an educator and AI-in-education consultant based in Montreal, working with English and French school communities. He is the author of Teaching in the Age of AI: The WISE Canadian Classroom. He offers staff workshops, consultations and talks through Edify AI.