What does structured student use look like?
Structured use means students are never guessing what is allowed. For each task, the rules say what AI may do, what it may not do, and what students must hand in. A workable pattern has four parts:
- Task-by-task rules. The same student may be allowed AI for brainstorming on Monday and barred from it on a Friday quiz.
- Documented use. Students note which tool they used, what they asked and what they did with the answer.
- Verified claims. Every factual claim from AI is checked against a real, non-AI source.
- Ownership. Students can explain and defend everything in the work with their name on it.
The broader approach is described in Can students use AI for schoolwork?
What might AI be allowed to do in each subject?
These are examples a teacher might adapt, not a standard. Your department, school and board may set different expectations.
| Subject | Might be allowed | Might not be allowed |
|---|---|---|
| English / language arts | Brainstorm topics, ask for feedback on clarity of a paragraph the student wrote | Drafting the essay or rewriting the student's voice |
| History and social studies | Suggest search terms, generate counterarguments to test a thesis | Supplying facts or sources the student has not checked |
| Science | Explain a concept in simpler words, suggest what to measure | Inventing data or writing the lab conclusion |
| Math | Explain a worked example, generate extra practice questions | Solving graded problems, since the reasoning is the learning |
| Arts | Spark ideas, name styles to explore | Producing the final piece presented as the student's own |
| World languages | Practice conversation, explain a grammar point | Translating or composing work meant to show the student's own ability |
How do you assess thinking and not only the product?
When a polished product is easy to produce, the evidence of learning moves to the process. Useful options include:
- A short use note listing prompts and what the student kept, changed or rejected.
- A brief conversation about the work, or a short written reflection of equal weight.
- Drafts or planning notes handed in along with the final version.
- A signed source check showing claims were verified.
Ways to rebuild tasks around these ideas are covered in How do you redesign assignments for the age of AI? If you want a ready-made model, the Position Paper Kit and Prompt-Portfolio Set are among the free resources.
What does a task-by-task rule look like on a handout?
Plain wording keeps rules usable. A teacher might write: "For this task you may use an AI tool to brainstorm and to check the clarity of your own writing. You may not use it to write sentences or paragraphs for you. Keep a short note of what you asked and what you did with the answer. Check every fact against a source you can name and find again."
Stating the reason behind a rule helps it feel fair rather than arbitrary. Rules should also be reviewed as tools and classroom experience change.
How should students acknowledge AI use?
Make acknowledgement routine and low-stress. A simple line at the end of the work is often enough, such as: "I used an AI tool to suggest outline ideas. I rewrote them and checked all facts against the sources listed." Honest declaration of permitted use should carry no penalty. Formats vary, so follow your school's expectations; see How should students cite or acknowledge AI use?
What about misuse and academic integrity?
Clear rules make fair responses possible. When a student uses AI outside the stated rules, the first response is educational: a conversation about what was allowed and why. Further steps should follow your school's policy. See AI and academic integrity for more.
How do you talk with secondary students about AI?
Some students know the tools well but have thought less about their limits. Ask what they use AI for, where it has been wrong, and where they think the line is. Then explain the reasoning behind your rules. Teaching students to ask well is part of the job too; see How do you teach students to write good AI prompts?
Where should a secondary teacher start?
- Choose one assignment and decide what AI may and may not do on it.
- Write the rule in two or three plain sentences on the handout.
- Ask for a short use note and a source check.
- Adjust based on what students hand in.
Quick answers
Should every teacher in a school use the same AI rules?
A shared school policy gives students a common baseline, but the best rules are set task by task. Teachers can add specific rules for an assignment as long as they stay within the school's policy.
Can students be asked to explain their work instead of handing in a product?
Yes. A short conversation or written reflection of equal weight is a sound alternative or addition, because it shows the student's own thinking.