QUESTION · FOR TEACHERS

Should teachers use AI to grade work or give feedback?

Teachers can use AI cautiously to help draft feedback wording, clarify rubrics or build comment banks, but the grade is the teacher's professional judgment and should not be handed to a tool. Student work contains personal information, and AI raises accuracy, fairness and trust concerns. Check your board's rules first.

Written by David Fineberg · Last updated

The grade is a professional judgment

Assessment is one of the core responsibilities of a teacher. A grade reflects what you know about the task, the learner and the learning goals. AI tools do not have that knowledge, and they can be wrong or inconsistent. In the WISE framework, the Endorse It pillar applies fully here: whatever AI helps you produce, you are accountable for it, and that includes every grade and comment a student receives.

Why caution is needed

Four concerns come up again and again.

  • Accuracy: AI can misread an answer, miss an error or praise work that does not deserve it, and it states its view confidently either way.
  • Fairness: AI tools can reflect patterns and gaps in their training data. They may treat different writing styles, dialects or backgrounds unevenly. See Is AI biased?
  • Privacy: student work often contains names, personal stories and other identifying details. See what student information should never go into an AI tool.
  • Trust: students and families expect that a teacher read and judged the work.

Check your board's rules first

Many boards and schools have set expectations about which tools may be used with student information, or about AI in assessment. These differ across Canada. Before trying anything, read your board's guidance and your school AI policy. If you cannot find it, ask your principal. A tool that has not been approved for student information should not receive any.

Good uses and risky uses

Lower-risk uses (no student work or identifiers involved):

  • turning your rubric language into plainer student-friendly wording;
  • building a bank of general comment starters you then personalize;
  • drafting example feedback on a made-up sample response;
  • suggesting clearer success criteria for a task you designed;
  • rewording your own comments to be kinder or clearer.

Risky uses (avoid or get clear approval first):

  • pasting real student work into a tool, especially with names or identifying details;
  • letting a tool assign marks or levels that you then record;
  • using a tool's judgment as the deciding factor in a close call;
  • sending report card comments linked to an identifiable student;
  • using the output without reading it carefully.

Be open with students

If AI helps with your feedback in any way, say so plainly. Students are being asked to be honest about their own AI use, and teachers can model the same openness. A short line works: "I used an AI tool to help reword my general comment bank. I wrote and checked all feedback on your work myself." Only say this if it is true, and only if it is allowed where you teach.

Do not rely on detectors or scores

The same caution applies to tools that claim to judge whether work was written by AI. Such tools can be wrong, and they should not decide a grade or an integrity case. See how a school should evaluate an AI tool for questions to ask before any tool is used.

Where to start

Begin with the lowest-risk use: ask a tool to help you reword a rubric you wrote, using no student information. Read the result critically, keep what helps and discard the rest. Keep every judgment about a student's work in your own hands.

Quick answers

Can AI save time on report card comments?

Only with great care. Comments tied to an identifiable student involve personal information, so follow your board's rules and never paste identifying details into an unapproved tool.

Free classroom-ready resources

Handouts, a sample school AI policy, a prompt-portfolio set and a printable WISE Compass poster. Enter your email to get them, plus new resources as they are added.

Get the free resources
Free · unsubscribe anytime
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

David Fineberg is an educator and AI-in-education consultant based in Montreal, working with English and French school communities. He is the author of Teaching in the Age of AI: The WISE Canadian Classroom. He offers staff workshops, consultations and talks through Edify AI.