Start with your board's process
Boards have their own procurement and privacy review processes, and a tool may need approval before any student or teacher uses it. Do not rely on a teacher's own checklist alone. Ask your principal or technology lead what the process is, and use the checklist below to prepare for it.
The checklist
- Purpose and learning value. What problem does it solve? Is there a clear learning benefit over a non-AI option?
- Student information. What does it collect, where does it go, and who can see it? Read the privacy terms. See AI and student privacy.
- Board approval. Is it approved or under review?
- Age requirements. What does the tool state about minimum age and parent or guardian consent?
- Accounts. Are student accounts required? Can the tool be used by the teacher alone?
- Cost. Is it free or paid, and who pays? Will families be expected to?
- Accessibility. Can all students use it, including those who use assistive technology?
- Data controls. Can data sharing be turned off? Can data be deleted?
- Transparency. Does the company explain how the tool works and its limits?
- Accountability. Who at the school owns the decision and handles problems?
- Review plan. When will the school look at it again?
Red flags
- No clear privacy terms, or terms that are hard to find.
- Requires personal details that are not needed for the task.
- Cannot turn off data sharing or delete data.
- Claims to detect AI writing or grade work with certainty. See AI grading and feedback.
- Pressure to adopt quickly, or promises of guaranteed results.
- No named contact for questions or problems.
A simple decision approach
- Yes: a clear purpose, satisfactory privacy terms, board approval and no red flags. Use it, and set a review date.
- Maybe: promising but with open questions. Pause and ask the vendor or the board for answers, or limit use to teacher demonstration with no student data.
- No: unclear privacy, missing approval, or any serious red flag. Do not use it.
Where to start
Pick one tool people are already asking about and walk through the checklist as a team. Document the decision, who made it, and what questions remain open. Keep a short record that other staff can read, so teachers do not each have to repeat the same review. If a vendor cannot answer a question in writing, treat that as useful information. School leaders can find wider context in Leading AI in your school and should connect decisions to the school AI policy.
Quick answers
Who should approve a new AI tool?
Follow your board's procurement and privacy process. Individual teachers should not adopt tools that collect student information without approval.
How often should approved tools be reviewed?
Set a review date when you approve a tool. At minimum, review alongside your annual policy review, because terms and features change.